Celestino's New York Pizza - Feedback

The downtown location has hands down the best pizza in Chico.

You won't find any new York style pizza anywhere in Chico as good as Celestino's or my name ain't Tony...it ain't Tony but the sentiment remains! Been to New Yo...

Never been disappointed with the pizza. Agree with everyone that delivery is not good, but takeout and sit in is awesome. They throw it into the oven again righ...

Love it!! Everyone was so nice and happy. It is a nice family friendly environment!!

New Yorker here!! Yuuurrrrr!!! These the Best NY style pizza in Chico! But I had to give it 3 stars is cause y’all missing the secret ingredient. That Hudson Ri...

Wow wow wow this place really made up to the promise of a delicious NY Style pizza. Stiff, small, crisp crust with a slight bend that allows for a great folded...

If you're looking for a quick and easy slice of pizza, Celestino's is the place to go. The slices are thin and crispy, and they taste just like the pizza you'd...

Some of the best NY style pizza you can get on the West Coast: thin, crispy, doesn?t collapse when you hold it up. Only a handful of places in SF and LA stand u...

Pizza always delicious. It?s now a walk up instead of a sit down restaurant but we loved getting our favourites none the less. They gave us free water on a hott...

The pizza is very good and the slices are large!!!! A lot of much flavor. Located right next to a park and Chico state You really will not be disappointed if yo...

I had their slices of Hawaiian Mushroom Pizza with a side salad and the size and taste was good. I also had a pesto ranch on the side, that was good too.

Best pizza ever, I tried all the dishes but mushroom one is my fave

Good size pizza, good convenient pizza by the slice, all well prized. Parking: plaza parking. Wheelchair accessibility: yes.

Original East coasters here…….this was by far the closest thing to East coast pizza we have found! Excellent!

A classic Chico staple I love coming here whenever I’m in town, it’s always a really good price for how much food you get and if you’re a student at Chico state...

Great bruschetta, good mozzarella sticks and the pizza is pretty splendid also! Service is very good also!

Celestino's delivery never disappoints. Despite changes in ownership, the quality has never wavered. The food is consistently satisfying and delicious, with som...

The staff is very friendly and the thin crust pizza is delicious! I highly recommend this place to anyone visiting Chico.

I absolutely loved the marinara sauce calzones and cannolis at this restaurant! The staff was friendly and the food was delicious, with reasonable prices. I'm s...

Celestino's has the best pizza in Chico hands down! Even my dad, who is a very picky pizza connoisseur, can't get enough of their delicious pies. Tonight, they...

Don't bother with the restaurant on the East side, the true gem is here at Celestino's on Salem. Their dishes are always fresh, made to order, and served prompt...

I highly recommend the pie at this restaurant. I was in town for the night, checked out the Yelp reviews, and I was not disappointed.