The Monster Crab All You Can Eat Seafood

Confusion with buffet sheets at the start of the visit which led to incorrect orders and missing elements from plates. The peeled shrimp was inedible for all who ordered and expressing that didn't lead to any changes to the order from staff. Took too long for orders to be refilled. Heavy on the garlic led to after taste that lasted all day.

Yummy food, cooked just right, the catfish po-boy was fantastic and the scallops in the broth bag was delicious. Waitress was attentive. Have been here a few times now and plan on returning.

I love seafood. This place is exactly what we needed in the area. Love getting a nice bag of scallops and shrimp doused in garlic butter! Also had the flounder po boy. Nice staff too.

I was so disappointed with my food, but I had to fake my smile for my mom because she wanted to come here so bad because of the all you can eat option. The seafood is loaded with garlic. It’s not enjoyable and it lax flavor voodoo crab Cajun bucket are better options for me.

I 've been looking forward to trying Monster Crab since they opened. The appeal of trying someplace new and closer than Popeis in Bethpage (always 5 stars) drew us in.Large, clean and attractive space. Serive was slow at first, but staff answered all of my tables questions and were quite pleasant. Unfortunately that didn 't make up for the poor quality of some of the food.The younger members of our party ordered fried chicken wings, French fries and fried shrimp which they were happy with.The adults started with salad which tasted like it hadn 't been thoroughly washed. I ordered the lemon pepper class and mussels which were delicious and then that was it. The shrimp tasted and looked like it had been previously frozen. I paid extra for crab legs and a lobster tail, both tasted old and were not cooked properly. The calamari was gross and also tasted old.I overheard the table behind me sending their food back to the kitchen because the food tasted off .The price for all you can eat on Sunday was very reasonable but the quality wasn 't worth it.