Oyster Bay Restaurant Bar - Feedback

My boyfriend took me here for my birthday. The ambiance is super fitting for a date night. I ordered the gumbo but it was amazing!!!! I never had gumbo taste th...

Great deal on oysters, food terrific and friendly service. Will definitely return. Great location.

Came here for happy hour of buck an oyster. They came through, had to wait a bit as the waitress said only one shucker. She seemed overwhelmed a bit and a bit s...

So disappointed.... The meal they were known for filet with crab meat and béarnaise sauce was no longer on the menu . Service was less than stellar , received n...

Finally tried this place after 30 years of Cape May dining.....can't believe I never made it in but BF and I decided to hit a bunch of places we've never been t...

Had dinner at Oyster Bay on Tuesday Aug.8th in the bar, Mike was our server / bartender, he made the best PAMA martini and also recommended the roast beef sandw...

I went with my mother and sisters to celebrate Mom's birthday. We got the fried tomatoes and crabs it was great. My sister and I have the seafood pots cake it w...

Excellent food and service, the Filèt and crab meats were phenomenal, Anne was our server, she treated my 2 friends and I very well, even though we young ladies...

We went to the bar for Happy Hour, Casual Attire, beautiful atmosphere, bartender very friendly and attentive, My husband got Rohaustern on the half shell that...

I was there last night for me and my wife's anniversary for the first time. I would recommend this restaurant to everybody I encounter. The bar maid Elizabeth w...

Gary, the “Manager” is the direct result of this poor review. After driving over 100 miles to have dinner with my family, we decided on this restaurant for some...

Had dinner, lobster tails, mash potatoes and veggies.... friend had the salmon... good eats, good service, friendly place... I'll go again... Service: Dine in M...

We wanted steaks and were willing to pay the price to get good ones. Unfortunately, none of the steaks at this restaurant were cooked to our specification. We a...

Parking: They have their own lot, but it can get crowded. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $30–50 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Parking o...

I always hesitate to give back poor ratings, but here today (Aug 2023), during our dinner, many things went wrong. We, a family of four, day 6 of our trip in th...