Acme Pie Company - Feedback

The most delicious pies I've ever had! Most highly recommended!!! Try something savory and take something sweet home for later.

Updated review: STILL 5/5 Pies: Crust is still amazing as always. Their pies aren't too sweet, so eating a slice doesn't feel like a struggle. Their fruit pies...

Quaint little pie shop is a hidden gem in Arlington, thank goodness we found it using yelp. The staff Anabelle and Lila were friendly and welcoming, had great s...

Came in 30 mins before closing on a Thursday. We were greeted nicely. There was a couple ahead of us ordering a bunch of slices. Older women comes from around t...

The only experience I've had with Acme Pie so far is with their Cookies which I discovered at a library function they were THE BEST!!! I plan to stop by one of...

Absolutely LOVE this place! Best pie I've had outside of my grandma's kitchen! Amazing!

I ordered the sour cherry and pecan chocolate for Thanksgiving and was utterly disappointed. The cherry was filled with an almost gelatin concoction which I tho...

I was in the mood for desert and a place to read the paper (yes I occasionally still read the paper on Sundays. Acme easily fulfilled both needs. It was a quiet...

I am visiting and stumbled upon the best pie I've had in the country. Good ice cream for the pie and a great pie flavor variety. Earned my first yelp review.

Stellar pie shop. I’ve never been let down and have tried most flavors. It’s hard to find a dessert place that specializes in pie.

had ordered a cake on the phone and when we showed up, they said they had not reserved this cake. the service was generally bad. ab mai also their social distan...

I love the blackberry cake here, and generally fruitcakes have been good (berries better than apple). The vegan quiches were simply ok, but it is still quite co...

I tried the blackberry lime, strawberry rhubarb, apple and spring berries. The crust is killer. My favorite was the blackberry lime, second was apple. Look forw...

I only have three cakes. They're all great. And the piestress was very helpful and accommodating.

Had ordered a cake on the phone and when we showed up, they said they didn't keep that cake. The service was generally bad. From May, their social distancing pr...

Very robust and deep pies, not sweet, but very good. As someone who is gluten intolerant and has sensitive teeth, I had no issues with the pecan pie or the blac...

Bought a Classic Apple Pie for a friend's birthday and it was a big hit! If you're a pie fan, you won't be disappointed! Friendly staff a cute atmosphere.

Got their pumpkin pie for thanksgiving. Looked so good had to have a slice a couple days early and it was delicious. So glad that I ordered from them and will d...

I ordered the sour cherry and pecan chocolate pies for Thanksgiving and I was completely let down. The cherry pie had a strange gelatin filling that I initially...

This pie shop is excellent. I have always been satisfied and have sampled most of their flavors. It's rare to find a dessert spot that focuses on pies.

Ordered a pie on the phone and when we showed up they said they didn’t reserve that pie. The service was generally poor. As of May, their social distancing prot...

I sampled the blackberry lime, strawberry rhubarb, apple, and springberry pies. The crust is outstanding. My top picks were the blackberry lime and apple, in th...

I just ordered three pizzas. They were all excellent. The pizza maker was very helpful and accommodating.

I really enjoy the blackberry pie at this restaurant, and in general, the fruit pies are all delicious (berries are better than apple). The vegan quiches are ju...

I absolutely adore the sour cherry pie at this restaurant! The service was top-notch and the atmosphere was polite and clean. It's a great spot to visit once CO...

The apple pie at this restaurant is simply amazing, with a heavenly crust. It's the first apple pie I've ever had that rivals my own mother's recipe!

The root beer float and Scottish apple pie with whiskey-soaked raisins were delicious!