Kingston's Fish Market - West Sayville

I had an incredible experience at Kingstons Fish Market! The customer service was absolutely outstanding (THANK YOU ANDY), and the freshness and deliciousness of their food never fail to impress. I'm a loyal customer because of the consistently phenomenal service and top-notch quality. Highly recommended!

We stopped by for some lunch on a warm, sunny Sunday afternoon. The hostess was very friendly and accommodating as we requested a table in the shade. We were about to sit down inside and she offered us a table by the water, in the shade that had just opened up. The bus boy cleared and cleaned the table quickly. Our server was very pleasant offering suggestions on their popular dishes. We ordered baked clams which were tasty and just the right size not tiny and not too big. I very much enjoyed the cold lobster roll. It’s quite possibly the best one I’ve had and I’ve tasted a decent amount of them. The dressing wasn’t overly thick with mayonnaise with just a touch of tarragon. The best part was the texture of the lobster…..full of chunks and claw pieces with just the right amount of celery. My companion enjoyed the burger. Just a straight up burger with cheese. Drinks reasonably priced. We will definitely be returning!

We come here every summer for our lobster roll experience. Thick, large chunks of lobster on a yummy roll. Your choice of tasty cole slaw or some really terrific fries. Nice atmosphere on the water. A wonderful accompaniment is a drink called, I believe, Watermelon Splash. You won't be feeling any pain, believe me! We order the cold lobster roll with yummy hot butter on the side, you can't beat it. Judging by the quality of this lobster roll, I am sure the rest of the seafood offerings are top notch. We must get to them sometime! Casual place, plastic utensils, unpretentious, excellent service, a lot of fun. Adds a touch of vacation to our summer.

Unless you’re a sailor, a fisherman, a mariner of some other sort, a drunk, and or a beautiful woman, please don’t come here. The place is perfect without the rest of ya.

Excellent spot for some fresh delicious seafood and a beautiful view of the Great South Bay .