Pizza Pie Cafe - Rexburg

It so good! I actually don't like pizza, but the noodles are a great option! The sauces are very good! They also have a salad bar which has fresh salad and a ton of toppings. The employees here are very hard working and kind. They also have dessert pizza which is delicious! The flavors they have are very creative! And they let you reserve party room ahead of time. I also love the decorations their too! Great restaurant!

I would say collectively this place would get a 2 10 for my husband and I. This is very much a great place more for like a high school cool hang out spot. The food was for us, over cooked on the pizzas, not the best. For us, we probably won't eat here again but I'm glad we atleast gave it a try.

I wish I could give these places no stars. I read an article somewhere claiming that this place was supposed to be good for the price of the buffet. Me and my roommate got so excited. We planned for this day for a week and then, today we went and the disappointment soon followed. The pizza dough is too chewy, both the dough and the sauces are overly sweet, the pizza was dry and looked as of it had be left there for several hours, and it left us feeling terrible after we ate it. For that experience, I would 've priced it at around $3 or $4 per adult buffet- and that 's being generous. I could only eat 4 slices before feeling depressed and sick but thought "I 've paid $12 for the buffet (including a drink and tip), I can 't just have 4 slices. I should have stopped there but I sucked it up and put more onto my plate and into my mouth. We left after sitting there for ten minutes starting blankly at the walls like pizza-driven zombies, trying to work up the courage to get more before realizing we 've been so demoralized by the pizza that we can 't eat anything else. Moral of the story: listen to your stomach and do your research before you eat somewhere new. Turns out there are a number of people that allegedly left with food poisoning. Not an appealing thought when you 're just looking for an affordable lunch.

Pizza was decent. The dessert pizzas were decent as well. The service from the employees were very very good. A recommendation I would suggest is the pizza shelves should be larger and there should be a direction of traffic for the food. It seemed to crowded. The men's bathroom toilet is not attached to the floor on one side causing the whole thing to rock sideways. The men's bathroom floor was wet and that tile is worse than ice when wet.

This place is a decently affordable place to eat dinner however, it's pretty hit or miss. I would say in my most recent trip that about 40% of the pizzas were well over cooked to the point that the dough was as hard as a cracker. And the dessert pizzas were worse. In fact I tried a small slice of each dessert pizza and was only able to finish the cinnamon roll one since all the others were incredibly overcooked. This made the affordable price almost negligible since I wasn't even able to enjoy a large portion of the pizzas. If you want salad the salad bar had a decent variety and at it least won't be burnt.