Carvel - Port Jefferson Station

I bought a birthday cake from this place and paid extra for fudge and crunchies. The cake looked decent in the box, but when I brought it home and took it out, I was shocked to see how short it was! There was barely any ice cream, fudge, or crunchies. I felt like I was ripped off, especially since these cakes are expensive. I called to complain, but was told the owner wasn't available and would call me back - which never happened. Needless to say, I won't be returning.

The service in this carvel is terrible, rip you off, charged me incorrectly, hardly put any ice cream in the cup and it was watered down. Support any carvel BUT this one ABSOLUTE DISGRACE

I always get my birthday cakes here with custom photos printed on them. They always come out great.

The staff was welcoming and the dining area was kept tidy. It could benefit from a renovation and possibly adding outdoor seating.

The staff at this restaurant is extremely friendly and efficient. The prices are reasonable and the portions are generous. Overall, a great dining experience.