Thatcher Mcghee's Pompton Lakes

Food was fantastic, fries were top notch. We got the pastrami sandwich and the fish sandwich. Service was excellent and friendly

Stuck in a nearby town for a big delivery. Lodging was easy enough to find but there was more than a handful of places to eat and none jumped out. So we chose this place and I gotta say I wasn’t impressed. Table service was excellent, nothing to improve on. Atmosphere was darkish, nothing stood out as special. Food was adequate but I guess I was expecting more. My coworker liked his meal up to the spinach. I’d be willing to try them again after trying other spots close by.

Thatcher’s in PL is so good in many ways. It has that town home feeling where everybody knows you and makes you feel welcome each and every time you dine there. The bartenders are ALWAYS incredible Tully, Ryan, Harrison and Jay and you cannot forget Christine! The best waitress is Diana and she always gives you her beautiful welcoming smile. Brendan, one of the owners, is so attentive to all of his customers needs and is always hands on with his crew. Aside from the people who work there….the food and drink is exceptional! It is a must go to place and you will get addicted to every aspect of Thatcher McGhee’s in Pompton Lakes!

First time here. Waitress was very nice Food was great! Sat behind hostess section they were a little bit loud taking about their lives. I would definitely come back.

Had dinner with the wife tonight. I had the Jameson chicken, she the beef stew. Food came out fast, tasty and on point. Mashed potatoes are kind of basic. 2 beers, 2 glasses of wine, 2 meals, tax and tip came to $67.