Sarah's Pizza - Oak Island

They sent wrong order and the person who answered phone couldn't understand English very well. Good food but I'll stick to my regular spots

I use to order from here almost every day poutin is what i got and most times it was good however sometimes it wasn't consistent like a few time there was very few fries in the large it happend aa few times never complain but finily i did i didnt ask for nothen just was letting them know i wasnt happy then the manger pretty much called me a lier but i dont know why cause i didnt ask for nothen just wanted my food to be right next time i order it so any ways they lost my business which i was spending over $100 every week there for well over 3 months but this is why i stoped thanks

Excellent pizza every time. Great customer service.

I rated Sarah 's a year ago as a 4. However our last few orders have not gone so well. For the 2nd time we placed an online order and for the 2nd time after an hr we called the store to be told sorry no one checked the tablet . Our order did arrive hot and fresh, however there were at least a handful of onions on an order specifically asking for no onion. After waiting almost 2 hrs I expected at least to be the correct order.

New favorite pizza place. I hope this one lasts longer then the rest. The poutine and donair plates are to die for And the pizza crust is so soft and melty.