Carmine's 44th Street Nyc - New York

Amazing food and service. Last night. Back tonight.

Our food was amazing! The service was great and the atmosphere was good. We'll be back at our next NYC visit!

Making a reservation and getting seated was the best part of our experience. Once seated everything went down hill. We waited over 25 minutes for our server to take drink orders. When our food arrived it was under cooked and they forgot our sides. Then the bus boy dropped food on my husband when clearing the table. We were very much looking forward to dinning here and it was a complete fail.

Very busy. Really feel guilty lingering. But this is New York and this is a New York kinda place. Food and service were very good. You feel like family. My third visit. I’ll be back.

Went there tonight and ordered Gliten free pasta with melted cheese, with meatballs and chicken on the side because the meatballs are not gluten free. We waited 45 minutes for our food as we didn't order a separate salad. The waiter was pleasant but the order was all wrong one it finally came out..It was gluten free pasta but the meatballs were all over the pasta. No chicken at all and no cheese melted either..we had an appointment that we were now late for so we ended up leaving after over an hour with no food..too bad because the people who sat next to us who arrived 30 minutes after us had there salad and pasta both before us and it looked amazing..