Alimentari Beach Montauk

It was my first time eating here, and I was extremely pleased. I find a lot of the food in Montauk to be subpar, but Alimentari is not one of those places! The bruschetta literally melts in your mouth, and the meatballs were so tasty. I can't wait to try their pizzas because I'll 100% be back!

The crispy artichokes were the highlight of our meal. The Caesar salad was properly doused in dressing. The clam pie was pretty good as well. There's outdoor seating available, next to a busy road. The playlist was very Brooklyn hipster. This place was packed on Monday around dinnertime, which speaks to the quality.

This place is gahdamn amazing. And one of the owners Gary is the absolute best. I could close my eyes and point to things on the menu to order and I'm confident it would all be 10/10. Montauk needs more great dining options like this. Get the spritz. And the espresso martini. Just get it all.

One of our favorite places in Montauk! Amazing service, food, location, and atmosphere! We booked a celebration of life luncheon here fairly last minute and they were nice enough to accommodate us. Our family and friends raved about the food... whipped ricotta, calamari, Caesar salad, penne bolognese, Italian sandwiches, and clam pizza... everything was delicious!!!! Can't say enough good things. We always love coming here but the entire staff made our event extra special for us and we'll never forget it

Came here for a birthday dinner with some work friends. Absolutely a great choice. The appetizers were spot on, the entrees were delicious, and the desserts were fantastic. Our service was also stellar. Thanks for a great night!