Pick Your Pie - Mayfield Heights

This place is closed for any sort of walk-in business and now you must buy wholesale (as a business) or use them for catering to get their products. Pie cups are $2.99 where I work which is expensive for about 3/4 cup of pudding with some crumbs on top.

Pick Your Pie nailed it! I actually purchased their Pumpkin Cheesecake in Fairview Hospital's cafeteria. I love that it's perfectly portioned and has no additives. This cheesecake was smooth, rich without being cloying and balanced with spice. The whipped cream was light and the graham cracker crumbs were buttery and crisp. Well done PYP!

Such a new, creative take on pie! Honestly could sit here all day and eat these delicious treats. I can't just recommend one item because they're all phenomenal

It's not even pie. What a waste of time and money, it's literally a cup of pudding mixed with cookie crumbs. You could make this stuff at home, very bad place don't recommend this place to anyone. And if I could I would put no stars but you at least have to put one star in your review.

Literally just a wad of cream cheese and graham cracker dust. Not pie. Yuck