Smithtown Seafood - gton-Fayette

First time in, definitely won't be the last. The blackened catfish and grits took me back to my southern roots, in all the right ways, the atmosphere was cozy and inclusive. Quick service, just the right combination of busy and clean respectively.

Everything was delicious! You order at a counter then go sit in the brewery, where then your food is brought out to you. We loved everything. Cod fritters were fantastic. Would absolutely order the Oyster Po boy again. They sold out of the lobster roll right before we ordered. They only have it sometimes. My friend had the Salad Supper with catfish and loved it.

First time but definitely not the last time visiting this gem… Service, food, and atmosphere were great

I had Smithtown Seafood for the first time this weekend and was very pleased. I rarely eat fish, but made this an exception and I'm glad I did. I had the fish and chips. The fish was perfectly flaky and had a very tasty breading. The portion size was also much larger than I expected. The fries were good. I was a bit disappointed in the hushpuppies. They were dense and didn't have the flavor profile that I look for in a good hushpuppy. They were still serviceable, though. My partner had the Oyster Mushroom Po'Boy and said it was amazing. The bread was overflowing, to the point that it was an impressive feat for her just to keep everything contained so she could eat it. I will definitely be returning in the future. I already know that on my next visit I will be trying the friend catfish.

Wonderful! Wonderful! Wonderful! Best seafood in Lexington. The venue is great as well. We don’t drink but the atmosphere was amazing with several different seating opportunities.