Joey Gerard's A Bartolotta Supper Club - Feedback

Table ordered a lot and divided ribs, lobster, skalopps, filet mignon. everything was good, nothing was excellent. the ribs were disappointing seemed cooked mor...

3 adults and 3 children, eating was amazing. the tablet and meat and cheese for the starter was an amazing presentation. the children ate on the children's menu...

Love, love, love Joey Gerard’s. Food and service are top notch. Highly recommend.

Great service and atmosphere. Food was very good quality and cooked well.

Food was sensational. Service was outstanding. Would go back again.

The retro supper club decor/music is very comfortable. The food was awesome; perfectly cooked 8 oz filet lamb chops. (Excellent (optional) relish tray). Service...

Joey Gerard's is a most pleasant restaurant. The food is always outstanding and wonderfully prepared. Extremely high quality. Service as always been most wonder...

Service and food was great. Our old fashions were mixed correctly (that's important to me) and our server was very attentive and informative. We will surely ret...

A classic supper club Steakhouse located in Greendale, a quaint suburb in Milwaukee. The place is warm with dark wood and a large bar in the front house. The re...

Came here with a large family group. The food and service was outstanding. Our server Brittany was top-notch. The steak I had was cooked to perfection!

Excellent server. Jody and wonderful bartenders. Scott and Whitney

The 8 oz. Filet was outstanding along with mushrooms and glazed carrots. I shared the Caesar salad with my husband. I would have liked to have been offered fres...

This was our first visit, and we enjoyed the supper club atmosphere very much. Loved menu items such as the relish tray and old-time drinks like the Singapore S...

Delicious food in generous portions. Good Brandy Old Fashioned drink. Just being in the building makes you feel like you are an important person. KEEP UP THE GO...

Great food , friendly service, would highly recommend.

We had a really nice anniversary dinner here. Expected a little more from the menu but the service was great!

Meal was only okay. Wouldn’t go back simply because it’s so expensive that it becomes hard to enjoy it. Felt tricked into spending $20 for a glass of wine that...

Burger and wedge salad were very tasty and our waitor was great! Super nice man and was on top of everything. Bartenders were also very nice and served great dr...

We love going to Joey Gerard’s! The Raw Beef and Inions and the Relish Tray are some of our favorites. Delish Old Fashioneds! Service is excellent!

Food wasn’t great. They raved about this cool oven but my Brussel sprouts were undercooked but still burnt and my steak was charred. Service was great and I lik...

I had a good experience at JG, but I would recommend a few changes. The French onion soup had too much onion and not enough broth. I would suggest reducing the...

I am surprised to see only a 3.5 rating for this restaurant! I recently visited for the second time to celebrate my husband's new promotion. I honestly feel lik...

My husband and I came to this restaurant to celebrate our Anniversary. Our server was very attentive and friendly. She explained the menu clearly to us. My husb...