Elkton Goodfellas

My husband and I eat here weekly! We absolutely love the food and the service is top-notch. Theresa is the best! Our order always comes out quick and piping hot. Of course the calzones take just a bit longer but they are stuffed and worth the wait. The pizza slices make a tasty, inexpensive and quick go-to for us when we are short on time. Kid-friendliness: Great family atmosphere and lots of options on the menu that even picky eaters will find something they will enjoy. Kids will love their mozzarella sticks!

Excellent food and service Greetings to my dear Miguelito

Delicious food! Great service and for the money.. the meat stromboli was big and filling.

While passing through I saw the name goodfellas and pizza by the slice thought maybe this was a hidden gem of good pizza,but I was horribly wrong. The sauce the fundamental part of a pizza pie all watered down no flavor, where is the garlic,onion,basil,crushed tomatoes? So much oil on the slice I could have used it for cooking another meal. For local mountain people it’s probably good but for real Italians it’s awful.

Straight up American diner, had what we wanted, prices were right on reasonable.