Pauly's Pizza And Coney Shack - Charles

Awesome first timer! Great double pepperoni double pizza and cheese bread. Will definitely be back!

Easy service for to go orders. Be warned, at times you have to wait 45+ min for a pick up order because they’re busy. They give my dog treats as we wait, good Missouri ranch on the side of the Za! I also like the Mozz

Great pizza in a great location! Convenient walking distance for us and they have plenty of benches for sitting outside. They also have fans running which makes it a lot cooler if it's hot out! We called ahead and our pizza was ready quickly and still hot when we got there!

Was watching Joel Hanson on YouTube today do a coney challenge found myself wanting a hotdog so I went on Google to find a gourmet style dog and was recommended Paulys Pizza and Coney Shack so I went found it odd that it was in Newtown a residential area so I was skeptical.... BUT LET ME TELL YOU the cashier and the manager were VERY patient explained how they dogs went so I ordered the Coney Combo with the meat sauce and waffle fries when I say at this moment my taste buds are DANCING that Coney hit EVERYTHING in my soul and it was close to them closing I didn't catch y'all name but if you read this YOU DID AMAZING

I really wanted to love this. We got a pepperoni and bacon that was not very good. I will go back once more to make sure it wasn't just an off day but so far not impressed. The coney was just okay as well.